v2025.08.19

TASK

Review and analyze the concept below. Rate it on a scale from 1 to 10 using the criteria listed. Then revise the concept toward a solid 10 and output the improved version. Preserve the original intent and any critical facts. If something is missing, make minimal, clearly marked assumptions.

EVALUATION CRITERIA

• Clarity of problem and solution
• Audience fit and value proposition
• Differentiation and defensibility
• Feasibility, risks, and mitigations
• Narrative flow, tone, and specificity
• Evidence, metrics, and next steps

OUTPUT FORMAT

1. Rating: X out of 10, one sentence on why.
2. Diagnostic: 3 to 6 bullets for strengths, 3 to 6 bullets for gaps.
3. Revised Concept: polished, human readable, sectioned document. Use clear headings. Prefer concrete details, examples, and crisp claims.
4. Improvement Summary: 3 to 5 bullets on how and why the revision improves the original.

CONSTRAINTS